- Recent research confirms that sustainable investment is more profitable for investors.
- History has shown that companies with a good ESG rating pay higher dividends, for example.
- Sustainably managed companies generally have a lower risk exposure.
What do financial analysis and investigative work have in common? Actually, quite a lot. Both involve pursuing leads and gathering evidence − exactly the methods used by the index provider MSCI to determine the precise advantages, in euros and cents, of sustainable investing.
The crime’s sequence of events: In April 2010, the explosion of the oil drilling rig Deepwater Horizon resulted in the worst maritime oil disaster to date. The culprit was quickly identified: the rig operator BP. The court’s ruling made legal history: BP has so far been forced to pay an approximate 65 billion US dollars in penalties and settlement payments − around 58 billion euros. The environmental catastrophe was also a disaster for investors: Between April and June 2010, the BP share price fell by around 50 % – and still hasn’t fully recovered.
In contrast to the traditional stock index MSCI EM, the MSCI EM ESG Leaders index − with its focus on sustainability − is a significantly better indicator of future performance.
is the rate by which the global volume of sustainably managed assets has grown since 2016
Companies with a good ESG rating generally have a lower risk exposure. One reason for this lower risk may be that these companies employ more stringent risk monitoring methods. This was obviously not the case with the Deepwater Horizon. MSCI consequently omitted BP from its sustainability index in early 2010 – shortly before the catastrophe on the drilling rig.
Having a good sustainability rating results in greater profitability and higher dividends. To give an example: The ESG-dominated emerging market index MSCI EM ESG Leaders grew by 179.52 percent from 2007 to 2019, whereas the traditional MSCI EM grew by 118.93 percent. Why? Because, among other things, companies that follow a sustainable strategy are more future-oriented, attract a more talented workforce and maintain a stronger culture of innovation.
Improving the ESG rating significantly enhances the performance, As shown by another MSCI survey. The index provider compared factors such as the long-term performance of companies that had improved their ESG rating with the performance of companies whose ESG rating had deteriorated. The result: In an analysis of industrialized nations over a timespan of nine years, companies in the first group grew by 12 points more than those in the second group.