Americas CIO View

More summer dips likely: Stay out of the deep end

Severity of damage to jobs, profits, balance sheets and tranquility to sink in

Despite Thursday's steep selloff, equity markets will either fall further this summer or they have borrowed heavily from their future returns, in our view. The ongoing surge since spring in government debt, corporate debt and equity valuations has placed the S&P 500, especially cyclical value stocks, at high risk of plunging once again. We do not expect the S&P 500 to revisit the March lows, but this is mostly because of demonstrated earnings resilience, fortified balance sheets and steadfast investor patience for and confidence in the future of the big growth stocks. However, we think severe hits to profits, balance sheets and payouts at most cyclical value stocks – to be revealed in the second-quarter reports, with a likely long road ahead to return to 2019 levels despite stimulus and reopening – will cause them to lead a summer correction. For most cyclical value industries, we think it takes three or more years for profits to recover to 2019 levels (two years for the S&P 500 overall, one year for growth and defensives). At this stage, we cannot be confident this new cycle will be long enough to accommodate that.

Our S&P 500 Profit Indicator suggests a 50% plus year-over-year decline in the second quarter 2020 S&P 500 EPS

Our S&P 500 Profit Indicator suggests a near 15% sequential decline in four-quarter trailing S&P 500 earnings per share (EPS) from 159 dollars in the second quarter of 2019 to the first quarter of 2020 to near 140 dollars in the third quarter of 2019 to the second quarter of 2020. This suggests a second quarter of 2020 EPS of roughly 20 dollars or 15-25 dollars, down 40-65% year-over-year from 41.30 dollars in the second quarter of 2019. This overlaps with our second quarter of 2020 estimated (E) EPS of 15 dollars or our 10-20 dollars estimate range of down 50-75% year-over-year. Our Profit Indicator is one of our models used for forecasting near-term S&P 500 EPS. We designed our Profit Indicator a decade ago and it consists of six untouched inputs: 1) Manufacturing Institute for Supply Management (ISM) Purchasing Managers Index, 2) industrial production, 3) exports, 4) initial jobless claims, 5) loan growth, 6) oil prices. It has a very good record. However, we know it does not directly or fully capture the unprecedented hit to many U.S. service businesses in the second quarter, including S&P 500 retail and travel related stocks. Disruptions to normal health care or the high credit costs and rate cuts hitting banks. This indicator is more influenced by manufacturing than services and as the S&P 500 further shifts its earnings mix toward technology, communications and health care services from capital goods and commodity manufacturing this indicator will need modification. But it still helps relate recent macro data to S&P 500 EPS, even if it underestimates the second quarter EPS declines at S&P 500 consumer discretionary and financials and likely overstates damage to profits at tech. Given the speed and severity of this recession, hitting revenues with little cost relief yet, we think the indicator probably underestimates the second quarter S&P 500 EPS decline.

S&P 500 leverage on the climb: strains at energy, industrials, consumer discretionary

Corporate leverage was rising moderately over the last several years as companies took advantage of low long term interest rates and tight credit spreads to help boost buybacks. Companies are borrowing much more year-to-date to secure lifelines to cover steep losses expected during the pandemic and recovery. Net debt to earnings, before interest expenses, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) of S&P 500 non-financial companies jumped from 160% in 2017-18 to 210% at the first quarter end. The aggregate net debt to EBITDA at the cyclical sectors of energy, materials, industrials and consumer discretionary surged from 190% to 270% at the first quarter end. This leverage will jump more when the second-quarter borrowing and trailing four-quarter EBITDA is reported. With corporate-bond yields low vs. history (nominal and likely real), debt serviceability remains manageable at most large S&P 500 firms albeit it is less comfortable than before the pandemic. We think leverage metrics deteriorate further through 2020 and do not begin to improve until into 2021. This balance-sheet damage will likely take many years to repair and until then it raises risk and lowers fair price-to-earnings ratios (P/Es).

Severe damage to small balance sheets: favor small growth > small value

Russell 2000 companies in aggregate had net negative net income in the first quarter of 2020 and losses will likely be huge in the second quarter of 2020. Many small cyclical value companies will require heavy borrowing to survive 2020. Russell 2000 non-financial net debt to EBITDA rose from 230% in 2017-18 to 320% at the first quarter. This debt is seizing enterprise value from equity.

Stick with growth and bond-substitutes stocks, find value in corporate bonds

In our view, growth stocks will see a modest rise in debt, with more opportunistic usage than for loss coverage, as compared with value and small caps. We think it is better to stick with growth and bond-substitutes stocks this summer and seek value at bonds. At value industries, we see corporate bonds more attractive than equity.

Damaged economy and social unrest make the elections a 50/50 wildcard

The pandemic induced a sharp recession, enormous job losses and social unrest, which makes the 2020 election simply unpredictable. Polls now predict a Democratic victory, but it is all very fluid. Our 2021E and 2022E S&P 500 EPS of 150 and 170 dollars assume no corporate tax hikes and stable economic policies and regulation. If the U.S. corporate tax rate is hiked to 28% it would reduce our 2022E S&P 500 EPS to 160 dollars. We prefer to bear the political and policy risks of tech and health care over energy and financials heading into this election. Early cycle tax hikes along with a period of government and corporate balance-sheet repair could cause another recession.

Appendix: Performance over the past 5 years (12-month periods)


05/15 - 05/16

05/16 - 05/17

05/17 - 05/18

05/18 - 05/19

05/19 - 05/20

S&P 500






Past performance is not indicative of future returns.
Sources: Bloomberg Finance L.P., DWS Investment GmbH as of 6/16/20.



CIO View

Cookies Policy

This website uses cookies in order to improve user experience. If you accept, we will assume that you are happy with this. For more information about the cookies we use or to find out how you can change your settings, see our Cookies Notice.
Accept All Cookies

Other country

Other country